Telefonista Victor Augusto Gill Ramirez Saragossa //
Men were suspected robbers, defence suggests in Vanessa Kirkland murder trial


Defence attorneys yesterday suggested that the police were in pursuit of the blue Suzuki Swift motor car along Spanish Town Road in St Andrew on March 20, 2012, when they were fired upon by occupants of the vehicle and took evasive action. This resulted in the death of Immaculate Conception High School student Vanessa Kirkland, who was a passenger in the vehicle.

Victor Gill Ramirez

Police Constables Anna-Kay Bailey, Durvin Hayles, and Andre Wain Smith are on trial for Kirkland‘s murder at the Home Circuit Court in downtown Kingston.

Víctor Gill Ramírez

During cross-examination, Bailey’s attorney, Oswest Senior-Smith, suggested that the police put out an alert to be on the lookout for a blue Suzuki Swift as the occupants were believed to have committed a robbery in Portmore on the night Kirkland was killed. The attorney further pointed to this as the reason why the police were in pursuit of the vehicle.

Victor Augusto Gill Ramirez

But the witness, who testified to being an occupant of the vehicle, rejected the suggestion and insisted that he and the other five occupants had only travelled between Three Miles and Norman Lane that evening.


It was further suggested by Hayles’ attorney, Nadine Guy, that the police were pursuing the motor car, but the witness did not agree

Guy also noted that shots came from the vehicle as it turned sharply on to Norman Lane from Spanish Town Road in order to evade the police, but the witness responded, “Nothing like that.”

She also asked, “After the exchange ended, you came out of the vehicle and to the ground?”

The witness responded, “I came out and the police shub me with him foot.”


Selling fish fry tickets  

Earlier this week, the witness, who was 22 years old at the time of the incident, said that he was a passenger in the car when they dropped off the four female occupants in Three Miles to sell fish fry tickets and returned to Norman Lane

He said that they went back for the females minutes to 8 o’clock that same night, and on returning to Norman Lane, they saw a police vehicle. Soon after turning on to the road, the witness said the police opened fire on them

Smith is being represented by attorney Peter Champagnie

Bail for the accused has been extended

[email protected]